2026-11-17 15:21
Lead-in: SpaceX Achieves First-ever Second-Stage Tower Catch Recovery, Bernstein Maintains Outperform Rating with $268 Target. Compared to $139 on Nov 13.
Second-Stage Recovery Breaks the One-Time Use Curse of Rockets
On the evening of November 13, SpaceX launched Starship Flight 15, its 15th test flight. The spacecraft completed 14 orbits around Earth within 22 hours and successfully deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites into their designated orbital slots.
Differing from Flight 14, this mission fully executed all orbital procedures. The most critical breakthrough occurred during reentry, as Starship’s second stage achieved tower capture recovery at the Starbase launch site.
This marks humanity’s first successful recovery of a rocket’s second stage. Bernstein’s Douglas Haney team noted that the capture was executed exactly as planned.
Currently, thermal protection tiles appear visually intact, though final assessment awaits disassembly and analysis by SpaceX’s engineering team. If confirmed reusable without major refurbishment, this Starship is expected to be directly assigned to Flight 16.
If traditional rockets are likened to passenger aircraft scrapped after each flight, second-stage recovery equates to retrieving the most expensive airframe and avionics systems intact. Bernstein estimates SpaceX revenue will surge from $18.67 billion in 2025 to $241.87 billion by 2027.
First-Stage Booster’s Ocean Splash Was an Intentional Risk Mitigation
Flight 15 was not flawless—SpaceX failed to recover the first-stage Super Heavy booster at the launch pad as originally planned.
During ascent, all 33 Raptor engines ignited normally. However, during the return burn phase, one engine failed to ignite.
Bernstein analysts conclude that a single engine failure alone would not have caused a landing failure. The actual trigger for abort was a low propellant warning; the autonomous system then directed the booster to splash down in the Gulf of Mexico.
Although the exact cause of the alert remains undisclosed, the firm speculates SpaceX intentionally avoided any risk of launch pad damage. Preserving the integrity of the launch infrastructure enabled the historic second-stage tower catch recovery.
Given SpaceX’s prior success in recovering boosters, this setback is viewed as a temporary deviation. Bernstein anticipates booster recovery will soon become routine, much like Falcon 9 post-2016.
Valuation Anchor: Betting on Space Computing by 2031
On the surface, SpaceX’s current $1.91 trillion market cap implies a forward P/E ratio of 96.4x for 2027—difficult to justify based solely on recent launch and Starlink operations.
Bernstein made a rare adjustment in its valuation model, using Adjusted EBITDA for 2031 as the core valuation anchor. The firm first calculated the segment’s enterprise value for 2030, then discounted it back to mid-2027, arriving at a $268 target price.
The model skips 2028 because business activity at that time remains confined to rocket launches, ground computing capacity, and early-stage Starlink deployment. Bernstein emphasizes that the true foundation supporting SpaceX’s trillion-dollar valuation is its orbital data center constellation.
Deploying and maintaining massive compute satellite constellations hinges on full reusability of Starship. Only by driving launch costs to extremely low levels can space-based computing achieve commercial viability.
Financial projections clearly reflect this explosive growth curve:
As profits accelerate starting in 2027, SpaceX’s enterprise value multiple will plummet from 282.4x in 2025 to just 13.6x.
Decade-Long Technological Lead with Four Key Execution Risks
Bernstein assesses SpaceX holds a technological lead of approximately ten years over all competitors in full rocket reusability. Since its initial coverage on July 7, 2026, with a $239 target, the firm upgraded to $248 on August 6, and further raised to $268 on October 26.
Nevertheless, high upside potential comes with stringent engineering and commercial prerequisites. Bernstein identifies four key downside risks:
First, Starship launch capacity expansion hinges entirely on successful validation of thermal protection system reusability. Should heat shield tiles require costly refurbishment, launch frequency will suffer significantly.
Second, orbital data centers represent a novel commercial model—SpaceX must demonstrate operational feasibility at scale.
Third, semiconductor supply constraints or bottlenecks in aerospace supply chains could delay satellite and compute node deployments.
Fourth, launch accidents triggering regulatory grounding, coupled with lower-than-expected market demand for space computing, would directly undermine long-term valuation.
Additionally, disclosure documents reveal that Bernstein and its affiliates provided investment banking and IPO underwriting services to SpaceX over the past 12 months and currently serve as market makers for its stock.
Institutional Ledger
Source: TechFlow Column
Disclaimer: Contains third-party opinions, does not constitute financial advice
AI technology stocks face the largest sell-off in a decade
08-06
After technology stocks double, they average a 40% drop the following year
08-05
NVIDIA Races for Speed, AMD Races for Volume: A $170 Billion CPU Battle
07-24
Google AI Doesn't Just Burn Cash: Cloud Revenue Up 82%
07-24
The AlphaGo Moment in Cybersecurity, or Starting from These 466 Agent Matchups
12 days ago
The Trump administration plans to offer Constellation Nuclear a $5 billion loan for capacity expansion, with the additional power mostly pre-allocated to AI giants such as Google
19 days ago
Silicon Valley Executives Spark Controversy Over Using AI for Household Tasks; Survey Reveals Half of American Adults Worry About Impact on Relationships
19 days ago






